Fatherland (2026)
Paweł Pawlikowski completes his remarkable trilogy of post-war European dramas with a haunting and beautifully photographed film featuring a superb Sandra Hüller.

Paweł Pawlikowski’s new film is his first since 2018, a lengthy gap, you might think, but this is par for the course for Pawlikowski. In the same way we once yearned for the release of a new Terence Malick film, you could argue the same now for Pawlikowski. However, there’s no doubting that the hushed reverence that once surrounded a Malick release has dissipated with his recent string of questionable films, whereas Pawlikowski rounds off his superb (loose) trilogy of films made about post-war Europe.
Fatherland is set in 1949, and amidst its very brief running time it tells the story of celebrated German novelist Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler), returning ‘home’ to Germany, firstly receiving an award in Frankfurt, named after the German polymath Goethe, who was born in the city. This is just the first leg of the tour, and we spend much of the film in the company of Mann and his travel companion Erika (Sandra Hüller), who also happens to be his daughter.
Plenty has been made of the proposed second award, to be presented in Weimar, where Goethe actually lived; now part of the communist East and controversial for its historical association with the Nazis. Mann hasn’t returned to his home country in decades, and part of the reason for his trip- and, more pertinently, his insistence on travelling to Weimar- is that he simply doesn’t feel like this is home anymore. His country has been so badly damaged, both geopolitically and physically by the war, that he now feels a real disconnect, approaching both zones with the same stunted indifference.
That’s not to say that Mann is beyond feeling. Zischler’s performance is remarkable in keeping it all behind his eyes, offering a grim outward reality that suggests, beneath all his work, a longing for what was once his home. But amid the ruin and rubble of the towns we travel through, astonishingly captured by Pawlikowski's regular Łukasz Żal, we slowly begin to discover what’s going on behind those eyes. This climaxes in arguably the year’s finest ending, a haunting and beautiful sequence in the ruins of a church.
Despite Mann being front and centre of the plot, the film is really Erika’s in many ways. This is a woman who also carries much but suffers no fools; a quite brilliant sequence when she meets her exhusband at a party is one of the best things you’ll see in 2026. The scene also features Joanna Kulig, star of Cold War, in a brief yet effective cameo as a singer. Erika deeply misses her brother Klaus (August Diehl), a writer in American exile who suffers from depression and whom Erika tries to persuade to join them on their ceremonial trip. Fatherland opens with a phone conversation between the pair, a simple scene yet one that brims with both resentment and familial longing.
Just like its predecessors, Ida (2013) and Cold War (2018), Fatherland is shot in a stunning sheen of black and white, bringing a real authenticity to the post-war surroundings. It almost feels like a film that was made in the time it’s set. The monochrome makes the journey through checkpoints, architectural ruins, and empty cafes weigh heavily, yet there’s always a sense of hope even in Fatherland’s darkest moments.
Pawlikowski packs so much emotional and historical heft into barely eighty minutes that it can be difficult to comprehend. But by focusing on such a story, it ensures Fatherland never strays into unnecessary territory, unlike, one could argue, Mann himself. While Zischler is brilliant as Mann, Hüller nails her position as one of the finest actors working today. It’s a quiet and affecting powerhouse of a performance, and one hopes that it will lead to an Oscar, something she should have already won for Anatomy of a Fall (2023) or Toni Erdmann (2016).
While Fatherland might not quite have the majestic sweep and intoxicating central affair of Cold War, to follow up one of the best films of the 21st century with something as good as Fatherland is impressive, to say the least. Here’s to hoping Pawlikowski doesn’t leave it quite as long next time.
★★★★
8.2/10





Comments